Signal vs Element: Which Offers Superior Encryption?
Discover the encryption prowess of Signal (US) and Element (GB). Learn how each app protects your messages with end-to-end encryption, ensuring your privacy in today's digital world.
Should You Switch to Element?
Gain GDPR compliance, self-hosting, and enhanced privacy controls.
Signal's disappearing messages and screen security features.
Switch if privacy and GDPR compliance are priorities; otherwise, stay with Signal.
At a Glance
US data laws
GDPR protected
Signal
Contact
Element
freemium
Privacy & Compliance Comparison
Critical data sovereignty factors at a glance
| Criteria | Signal | Element |
|---|---|---|
Server Location | US | EU |
GDPR Compliance | Unknown | Full |
Open Source | ||
E2E Encryption | All plans | |
Data Portability | Unknown | Full export |
CLOUD Act Notice
Signal is a US company and must comply with CLOUD Act data requests, even for data stored in EU data centers. Element is not subject to US jurisdiction.
Signal
🇺🇸Signal
Element
🌍Element
US Data Storage
Data subject to US CLOUD Act and may be accessed by US authorities
EU Data Protection
Data protected under GDPR with EU-only data residency
Certifications & Compliance
No certifications listed
Reasons to Switch
- ✓Matrix protocol allows interoperability with other messaging platforms.
- ✓Self-hosting options enhance privacy and control over data storage.
- ✓Group chats can accommodate up to 1000 members, ideal for large teams.
- ✓Data retention policies align with GDPR, ensuring compliance in the EU.
Things to Consider
- !Migration from Signal may involve data loss and user adjustment.
- !Element's interface may require a learning curve for new users.
- !Lacks built-in disappearing messages feature found in Signal.
Migration Overview
Depends on data size and complexity
Quick Steps
Create Element account and configure settings
Export and prepare data from Signal
Import data, test integrations, and migrate users
Note: Element's decentralization and self-hosting options provide excellent privacy, but the setup can be complex for non-technical users.
Other alternatives to Signal
.png)
Ready to make the switch?
Start using Element today and take control of your data privacy.