Okta vs Keycloak: Which Offers Superior Data Security?
Explore how US-based Okta and EU's Keycloak stack up in safeguarding your data, focusing on privacy laws and regional compliance.
Should You Switch to Keycloak?
Enhanced privacy and control over user data with Keycloak.
Potential loss of advanced features and integrations.
Switch if privacy is a priority; stay with Okta for features.
At a Glance
US data laws
GDPR protected
Okta
Contact
Keycloak
Contact
Privacy & Compliance Comparison
Critical data sovereignty factors at a glance
| Criteria | Okta | Keycloak |
|---|---|---|
Server Location | US (AWS), EU (optional) | Self-hosted (depends on user setup) |
GDPR Compliance | Full | Full |
Open Source | ||
E2E Encryption | Enterprise only | Optional |
Data Portability | Partial | Full export |
CLOUD Act Notice
Okta is a US company and must comply with CLOUD Act data requests, even for data stored in EU data centers. Keycloak is not subject to US jurisdiction.
Okta
🇺🇸Okta
Keycloak
🇪🇺Keycloak
US Data Storage
Data subject to US CLOUD Act and may be accessed by US authorities
EU Data Protection
Data protected under GDPR with EU-only data residency
Certifications & Compliance
No certifications listed
Reasons to Switch
- ✓Keycloak is open source, allowing for custom modifications.
- ✓Self-hosting enables full control over data and compliance.
- ✓GDPR compliance is built-in, reducing legal risks in EU.
- ✓E2E encryption can be implemented for enhanced security.
Things to Consider
- !Migration may require significant effort and technical expertise.
- !Keycloak lacks some advanced features found in Okta.
- !Learning curve for new users unfamiliar with open-source tools.
Migration Overview
Depends on data size and complexity
Quick Steps
Create Keycloak account and configure settings
Export and prepare data from Okta
Import data, test integrations, and migrate users
Other alternatives to Okta
Ready to make the switch?
Start using Keycloak today and take control of your data privacy.